This has been sitting my drafts for a few weeks. I'm just going to post it!
-------
Of course there's something going on with my family and, of course, it involves my sister. Unfortunately, it also involves her kids.
Lately my sister has taken to withholding the grandchildren from my parents. Why? Because they don't approve of the verbal abuse heaped upon the kids-mainly the oldest (the one from the college fling) while the younger of the boys doesn't seem to be degraded and disciplined as harshly (this one from the marriage with a different father). There is also another young one, a little girl less than 2, but she does not seem to be afflicted yet.
*NOTE* my parents don't use the term verbal abuse when talking about this, I do.
My parents stood by for years and let my sister parent as she would and choose a husband that was verbally abusive to my oldest nephew from before they were married-when this child was only 2 or 3. He is known for taking him away and yelling fiercely into his face with insults and reprimands usually resulting in tears and flinches.
He is NOT always the worst-in fact, he's a great guy when he's not overcome by his anger issues and emulating his father's parenting style. It is so sad how he criticizes his family for how he was raised, but doesn't seem to see the same mistakes repeating themselves in his parenting choices.
Well, a few months back things came to a head with my parents and my sister and her husband. My sister and her husband are known for FaceTimes and phone calls to my parents where they scream and complain-my mother handles it quite well and calmly I've been told (my brother witnessed one of the calls). She's born the brunt of the rage while my father only recently became directly involved after saying something in defense of my mother to my sister/brother-in-law. Now they're both in the ring.
It's sickening. I don't see children as currency and I don't see how it makes sense to withhold the kids from people that want them to be treated better. My sister takes the feedback quite personally (I can understand) and cannot stand to see the parents when the conflict escalates. Her husband is also quite torn up and I believe they both seek approval from my parents (which I believe makes everything worse but makes sense to me as well-I think if they didn't have seeds of doubt and seek approval they wouldn't be so bowled over my criticism).
I don't know how it will resolve. My mother predicts that the oldest nephew will choose to live with his biological father at some point. He already tried to run away a couple years ago, but they got my mother on the phone with him to talk him down. I don't see the kids very often, though I've witnessed the issues at hand, but my mom is seeing changes-negative changes-in their behavior and psychological wellbeing.
My sister has yet to ask my opinion. She's only ever asked if I've been told by our parents that that my "parenting is bad." I was honest, that I've received some feedback about not being involved enough, but I take it as feedback and I can see some truth in it even, but that's it. I think she knows that I don't approve of her parenting choices and I don't think she wants our parents' observations to be corroborated.
Her defenses have included a statement like, "[husband] had it so much worse," which to me is an admission of guilt. She's told my parents that they're raising leaders and are strict with their kids, but there is a line there that we believe has been crossed. Strict doesn't have to be denigrating and abusive. Strict doesn't have to be yelling and insults.
It makes me sad. Emotional abuse doesn't leave visible marks and our society just doesn't have a way to intervene right now. I know what goes around will come around, but it's not about them getting their comeuppance-it's about those kids' futures.
All the while, and I know this might be selfish, I'm so glad to be these hundreds of miles away. It's hard enough to remain neutral and support my sister and my mother as best I can (my mom has emphasized many times she wants me to be there for my sister while she can't).